Did You Hear the One About the Agent Who Sold that Home…?

You are currently browsing comments. If you would like to return to the full story, you can read the full entry here: “Did You Hear the One About the Agent Who Sold that Home…?”.

  1. I have been an Exclusive Buyers Agent for 20 years and I would consider your response a “turn off”.

    I would never ask a listing agent to call me as that would be a waste of time for them. I would however like to get a straight answer if I asked if there were other offers and the agent should have asked that question when they took the listing.

    The thought of a seller not wanting another buyer to know if there is another offer is unrealistic….because buyers will almost always offer MORE if they think there is another offer on the table.

    Eve Alexander

  2. What a great agent! What a great and ethical way to represent your client. This is a true representation of agency and what it means to be an honest and ethical Realtor! You are my hero!

  3. Eve, you are right it is a turnoff to some agents. A few agents have said what you said. But as Kymberley said it…..its about representing your seller. And its in the code of ethics! Theres no reason for a seller to show you their cards if the buyer doesnt show theirs. Meaning, sure Ill tell you how many offers I have…right after you tell me how high your buyer is willing to pay. You can check out my blog and see homes that we sell for more than the neighbors largely in part to this script.

  4. Marci Braddock

    Eve, some buyers will offer more. But just as many Buyersdon’t want to get into a bidding war and will cross that house off their list entirely. It’s a bit of a double-edged sword. The New Mexico listing agreement asks the question up front and requires that the Seller make the decision as to whether the existence and terms of offers is divulged to other Brokers. Some brokers will address it on a case-by-case basis, with a written amendment, as the listing goes on.

  5. The Listing Agreement that I have with my client allows me to disclose the existence of other offers and whether or not they are direct. Of the 3 choices in item 9 of the Greater Boston RE Board Exclusive Right to Sell Agreement, this is the one I always recommend my sellers initial.

    Brokers who ask me to notify them if there’s other interest clearly don’t know what they’re doing and are, essentially, undermining their buyer-clients’ chances of getting the property they want. I will, in the future, tailor your response when this situation arises, as I am often dumbstruck by this question.

  6. Liz Lockhart

    What I usually answer, when asked “Do you have any offers” is simply that the property is still available. If an offer has been accepted, I say that one has been accepted (if I am allowed to do so). When I will not elaborate, it is because I cannot do so, either in recognition of my client’s best interest or due to my specific contractual obligations.

    I wrote a blog about this very topic, and the discussion was heated at times. http://activerain.com/blogsview/2084917/do-you-have-any-offers-yet-

  7. jim f

    You can’t give that information away ! You put the house on the table for offers and you take offers, plain and simple. If someone wants to know what the other offers are or even IF they exist, THAT’S NOT YOUR PROBLEM. Your duty to your seller demands that you work in THEIR best interest NOT some poker player trying to squeeze info out of you. No way would I ever tell a prospect about the status of other offers. Put up or shut up.

  8. liuba

    NOT IN CALIFORNIA. The listing agreement by C.A.R. (California Association of Realtors) has a built-in clause authorizing the Broker to disclose to any real estate licensee making an inquiry the receipt of any offers on the property and the offering price of such offers.
    It really helps to gauge the market to know what properties are getting 2, 12, 25 or 50 offers. We are in the 25’s and 50’s on # of offers received for properties listed in the $300,000s right now.

  9. Nato

    I agree with your response which prompted an offer; however, You should discuss this when getting a listing agreement. You must discuss with the seller when and what you want to disclose to buyers. In Colorado an agent representing the seller is suppose to pursue and obtain the “best” offer. Once I get multiple offers I disclose to the buyer’s agents the facts, there is a better offer on the table, you have until “x” time to resubmit your offer. Call it what you want but the seller who I represent, gets to choose the highest and best offer and I fulfilled one of my many duties as their agent.
    Note: The better offer may be higher earnest money, close quicker, higher price, etc.

  10. Don Bass

    I feel that many people that read this are missing the point. This house in particular had no interest for many years. An agent tells him that their buyer is interested but wants to look at other homes (shop around) because this was their first home that they have seen. So in order to not let this agent and buyer shop around while his listing sits there the listing agent said something very truthful and ethical and in turn got his seller an offer and sold the house. Sometimes people try to complicate things and make up what ifs and the point gets muddied up and lost. Keep it simple and see it for what it is.

  11. Marci Braddock

    The BEST response to this question?

    “Get me your best offer as soon as you can.”

    It doesn’t disclose anything (unethically or against your seller’s wishes) but it certainly creates a sense of urgency!

  12. Pat Howell

    For clarification, I copy and pasted this from the NAR 2013 CODE OF ETHICS, ARTICLE 1, Standard of Practice 1-15

    REALTORS®, in response to inquiries from buyers or cooperating brokers shall, with the sellers’ approval, disclose the existence of offers on the property. Where disclosure is authorized, REALTORS® shall also disclose, if asked, whether offers were obtained by the listing licensee, another licensee in the listing firm, or by a cooperating broker. (Adopted 1/03, Amended 1/09)

  13. Linda l. pISANELLI


  14. Linda l. pISANELLI

    How do I get into the course on Ethics ?

  15. Curtis

    This topic is all very interesting and it highlights another reason that Code of Ethics should be one of the annual mandatory courses. Sure, it can get boring and some may say “why do I need to learn this stuff every year…I know it already!” But look around our association and office and you’ll see agents who write a lot of listings and sales contracts; then there are those who seldom write a listing or sales contract. Every time I attend or teach this course I don’t mind saying I learn something and that is the way it should be with something as important as COE. If you know the COE back-and-forth; good for you. But what about the agents you’ll be cooperating with to get that listing sold or that offer accepted and closed. The more everyone around you knows the easier the transaction will go and the better YOU will look to your clients. Remember this – things change; the attitude, knowledge, patience and demands of the clients we deal with are constantly changing and we must be as on top of our profession of managing “the most important purchase or sale most people will every make” by knowing what we can and can not do – “The Code!” I look forward to your comment pro or con.